Karnataka HC Clarifies Independent Witness Need Not Personally Believe Reputation Lowered for Defamation Cognizance under BNS Section 356

HC News

Karnataka HC Clarifies Independent Witness Need Not Personally Believe Reputation Lowered for Defamation Cognizance under BNS Section 356

The Karnataka High Court ruled that a magistrate may take cognizance of criminal defamation under Section 356 BNS without an independent witness testifying that the complainant's reputation was lowered in their own estimation, provided the imputation is inherently capable of lowering moral or intellectual character.

Hydar Choudhury
4 min read

Follow Jurisight:TelegramWhatsApp

Karnataka HC Clarifies Independent Witness Need Not Personally Believe Reputation Lowered for Defamation Cognizance under BNS Section 356 — HC News Legal Analysis | Jurisight
This article was prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the Jurisight Desk.

The Karnataka High Court has clarified that an independent witness is not required to personally believe a complainant's reputation has been lowered for a magistrate to take cognizance of a criminal defamation complaint under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023. Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde held that the necessity of such testimony depends on the nature of the allegedly defamatory statements, the material available, and the surrounding circumstances.

What is the legal standard for taking cognizance in criminal defamation cases under BNS Section 356?

If the imputation is inherently capable of lowering the complainant's moral or intellectual character, a magistrate may take cognizance and issue process based on statements that the reputation was lowered in the estimation of others, without requiring a witness to personally believe the reputation was diminished.

The ruling came while dismissing a petition filed by expelled BJP legislator Basanagouda Ramanagouda Patil Yatnal, who sought to quash criminal defamation proceedings initiated on a complaint by Congress leader Shivananda S. Patil. The complaint, filed on July 18, 2025, alleged that Yatnal made defamatory statements against Patil on April 30, 2025, broadcast on the YouTube channel 'Gadinada Kranti'. Yatnal challenged the magistrate's order taking cognizance and issuing summons, and the Sessions Court's order affirming it.

Yatnal contended that the trial court could not take cognizance merely on the complainant's statement and two witnesses, arguing the requirements of Explanation 4 to Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), corresponding to Section 356(1) of the BNS, were not satisfied. He submitted that unless a person whose estimation of the complainant had actually been lowered testified to that effect, the essential ingredients of criminal defamation would not be established. Counsel for the complainant argued the statements were defamatory on their face and widely circulated on social media, and the magistrate was not required to insist on testimony from a person who personally believed the reputation was lowered.

Explanation 4 to Section 356(1) of the BNS provides that an imputation harms reputation only if it directly or indirectly lowers a person's moral or intellectual character, standing in relation to caste or calling, credit in the estimation of others, or causes the person to be regarded as being in a disgraceful bodily condition. Examining the provision, the High Court observed that the expression "in the estimation of others" does not necessarily mean the particular person whose opinion was allegedly affected must invariably be examined as a witness at the stage of taking cognizance. The Court said possible reputational harm could, depending on the nature of the allegations and available material, be prima facie inferred from the contents of the allegedly defamatory statement and the circumstances surrounding its publication.

IPC Section 499 Explanation 4 vs BNS Section 356(1) Explanation 4

Provision

Statute

Key Text

Explanation 4

IPC Section 499

Imputation harms reputation if it lowers moral/intellectual character, standing in caste/calling, or credit in estimation of others, or causes disgraceful bodily condition.

Explanation 4

BNS Section 356(1)

Identical language: Imputation harms reputation if it lowers moral/intellectual character, standing in relation to caste or calling, or credit in the estimation of others, or causes the person to be regarded as being in a disgraceful bodily condition.

In the present case, the Court noted the two witnesses examined had stated they continued to hold a good opinion of the complainant and considered the allegations false. However, they also stated the allegations had lowered the complainant's reputation in the estimation of others. The Court observed that while the witnesses had not identified the particular persons whose opinion had allegedly changed, the nature of the statements attributed to the petitioner and the mode of their publication on a widely accessible YouTube channel were factors the magistrate could consider at the cognizance stage.

The Court held that where the allegedly defamatory statements are inherently capable of lowering a person's reputation, the magistrate may take cognizance and issue process without insisting on a statement from a witness that, in his own estimation, the complainant's reputation is lowered. However, where the statement is not prima facie capable of lowering reputation, a mere assertion that reputation has been lowered may not suffice, and the magistrate may require additional material or testimony from an independent witness stating the reputation was lowered in the witness's own estimation.

Applying this reasoning, the High Court found no infirmity in the magistrate's order taking cognizance and the Sessions Court's order affirming it. The petition was accordingly dismissed.

Hydar Choudhury

More stories by Hydar