A Division Bench of the Telangana High Court, comprising Justice K. Lakshman and Justice K. Sujana, has ruled that neither a Family Court nor a High Court can grant a decree of divorce solely on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The Bench clarified that while such breakdown cannot serve as an independent statutory ground, it may be considered along with other aspects while adjudicating an appeal for divorce.
Background of the Appeal
The appeal was filed by an engineer settled in the United States, challenging the Family Court's dismissal of his petition for dissolution of marriage. The marriage was solemnised in February 2002, and a son was born in 2005. The appellant sought divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, alleging cruelty and desertion. He claimed the respondent insulted his family, frequently left the matrimonial home without cause, and had a son from a pre-marital affair. He further stated that the respondent left for her parental home in October 2004 during her pregnancy and never returned.
The appellant had obtained a divorce decree from a Texas court in 2009 but was advised to secure a decree from a competent court in India. The respondent contested the petition, alleging that the appellant's family demanded additional dowry and refused to take her and her son to the United States.
Failure to Prove Cruelty and Desertion
The High Court examined the evidence and concluded that the appellant failed to substantiate the allegations of cruelty. The Bench noted that serious allegations were made regarding the respondent having a son from a pre-marital relationship, but no evidence was produced to support the claim. The court described the assertion as a bald allegation without corroboration.
Regarding desertion, the court held that the appellant failed to establish the essential ingredients, including factum of separation, animus deserendi, absence of consent, and absence of reasonable cause for leaving the matrimonial home. The evidence indicated that despite mediations and panchayats, the parties did not reunite, a fact evident from the depositions of prosecution witnesses and defence witnesses.
Can Irretrievable Breakdown Alone Sustain a Divorce Decree?
Neither the Family Court nor the High Court can grant a decree of divorce solely on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. The Bench observed that although the parties had been living separately for 20 years and there was no possibility of reunion, the statutory framework under the Hindu Marriage Act does not recognise irretrievable breakdown as an independent ground for divorce. However, the court held that this factor can be considered along with other aspects while deciding the appeal.
Court's Disposition and Conditional Decree
Despite the failure to prove cruelty or desertion, the Bench took note of the complete breakdown of the marital relationship. The appellant had been residing in the United States for 21 years, and the respondent had also acknowledged the filing of divorce proceedings in the US. In view of the totality of circumstances, the court dissolved the marriage by a decree of divorce, conditional upon the appellant paying an amount of Rs 50,00,000 to his son within three months. The court granted liberty to the son to initiate proceedings against the appellant in case of default.
Ground Pleaded | Statutory Provision | Finding of the High Court |
|---|---|---|
Cruelty | Section 13(1)(ia), Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 | Not proved; allegations of pre-marital son unsubstantiated |
Desertion | Section 13(1)(ib), Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 | Not proved; essential ingredients not established |
Irretrievable Breakdown | Not a statutory ground under the Act | Considered as a relevant factor alongside other circumstances |
The judgment reiterates the position that judicial forums cannot create new grounds for divorce beyond those enumerated in the statute, even where the marriage has factually collapsed. The decree was granted in the exercise of appellate discretion, factoring in the prolonged separation and the impossibility of reconciliation, subject to the financial condition imposed for the welfare of the child.
