The Madhya Pradesh High Court has held that a member of an undivided family retains the right under Section 4 of the Partition Act, 1893 to purchase the share of a dwelling house transferred to a stranger, even at the stage of execution of a partition decree. The bench of Justice Ashish Shroti clarified that the provision can be invoked during execution proceedings provided the statutory requirements are satisfied and the claimant submits an undertaking to purchase the share.
Can a Family Member Claim the Right to Buy a Stranger's Share Under Section 4 of the Partition Act at the Execution Stage?
Yes. The Madhya Pradesh High Court held that the right under Section 4 of the Partition Act, 1893 can be exercised even during execution of a partition decree if the property is a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family, the share has been transferred to a stranger, and the transferee seeks partition, provided the claimant furnishes an undertaking to purchase the share.
Factual Background
The dispute concerned a double-storey house in Guna jointly purchased by the appellant and his real brother in 1999. In 2005, the brother sold his half share to Respondent No. 3, an outsider, for Rs 1.20 lakh through a registered sale deed. The appellant stated he was unaware of the transaction until March 2012, when he received a legal notice from the purchaser. Asserting a preferential right to purchase his brother's share as a co-owner, the appellant filed a suit seeking a declaration that the sale deed was null and void and a permanent injunction against the purchaser. The purchaser opposed the suit and filed a counterclaim for declaration of ownership, partition, and separate possession of the purchased portion.
Proceedings in Lower Courts
The trial court dismissed the appellant's suit and decreed the purchaser's counterclaim. The First Appellate Court affirmed the decision, holding that Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 was inapplicable because the property had been jointly purchased by the brothers and had not devolved upon them through inheritance. The matter then reached the High Court in second appeal.
High Court's Analysis on Section 4 of the Partition Act
The court examined Section 4 of the Partition Act, which enables a member of an undivided family to purchase the share in a dwelling house transferred to a stranger when the transferee seeks partition. The bench observed that the provision is intended to prevent strangers from intruding into a dwelling house occupied by other family members and to protect their peaceful enjoyment of the common house.
The court found that all statutory ingredients for invoking Section 4 were satisfied: the property was a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family; the appellant and his brother each held a half share; the brother had transferred his share to a stranger; and the purchaser himself had filed a counterclaim seeking partition. The only outstanding requirement was the appellant's undertaking to purchase the share, which he had submitted during the appellate proceedings.
Rejection of Procedural Objections
The purchaser contended that the appellant could not furnish the undertaking at the second appellate stage and that invoking Section 4 at this stage amounted to a shift in the case. The court rejected both arguments. It reiterated that the right under Section 4 can be claimed even at the execution stage of a partition decree. On the alleged change of stand, the bench noted that the plaint itself contained an assertion of the appellant's preferential right to purchase his brother's share. The court stated that the plaintiff had challenged the defendant's sale deed on the basis of his preferential right to purchase the share of the first defendant, and therefore there was no shift of stand contrary to the averments in the plaint.
Stage | Finding |
|---|---|
Trial Court | Dismissed appellant's suit; decreed purchaser's counterclaim for partition and separate possession. |
First Appellate Court | Affirmed trial court; held Section 22 of Hindu Succession Act inapplicable as property was jointly purchased, not inherited. |
High Court (Second Appeal) | Allowed appeal; held Section 4 of Partition Act applicable even at execution stage; appellant entitled to purchase stranger's share upon furnishing undertaking. |
Scope of Section 2 of the Partition Act
The bench also addressed the scope of Section 2 of the Partition Act, noting that it applies when a suit for partition is instituted by a transferee of a share in a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family. The court emphasised that the legislative intent behind Sections 2 and 4 is to safeguard the residential character of the family dwelling and to prevent fragmentation caused by the induction of strangers.
Operative Outcome
The High Court allowed the second appeal, set aside the concurrent judgments of the lower courts, and decreed the appellant's suit. The appellant was directed to deposit the purchase price as per the undertaking submitted during the appeal, upon which the sale deed in favour of the stranger would be rendered ineffective to the extent of the purchased share, and the appellant would be entitled to have the share transferred in his name.
