The petitioner challenging the functioning of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has told the Supreme Court that the Election Commission of India's post-petition corrections constitute admissions that key decisions regarding the Special Intensive Revision were taken without the mandatory decision of the three-member Commission under Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
The submissions were made through a consolidated rejoinder affidavit filed by Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh in Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors, through Advocate-on-Record Mudit Gupta. The matter is pending before a Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana.
What Is The Core Legal Issue In The Challenge To CEC Gyanesh Kumar's Functioning?
The petitioner contends that the Election Commission is a constitutional body requiring decisions by unanimous or majority vote under Article 324 and Sections 17-18 of the 2023 Act, not by unilateral action of the Chairman or officers, and that the ECI's own admissions reveal decisions were implemented without such a Commission decision.
ECI's Defence And Petitioner's Rebuttal
The ECI had argued that its counter affidavit was approved by a unanimous decision of the three members, contending that these admissions bind all members including the Chief Election Commissioner. The petitioner rejects this framing, stating that "unanimity in defending an act is not unanimity in deciding it." He frames the case as raising one narrow question: whether acts done in the Commission's name were decisions taken unanimously or by majority as mandated by the Constitution and the 2023 Act, or whether they were taken by one member or by officers without any such decision.
The rejoinder lists specific admissions from the ECI's affidavits. These include steps taken by officers "which needed to be corrected to ensure that they are fully aligned with the steps approved by the Election Commission," an SIR declaration "entered into the online page of Form 6" in a manner that "could be construed as though an amendment of Form 6 had been made," and an internal work order of July 28, 2026 issued by an officer on deputation that was "never implemented" only because the two Election Commissioners jointly directed so.
Constitutional And Statutory Framework
On the law, the petitioner relies on Article 324 vesting power in "a Commission," not its Chairman, and the Constitution Bench ruling in T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995). That judgment rejected the view that Election Commissioners are advisers whose opinions the CEC may override, holding that treating the CEC's word as final would render them "non-functional or ornamental."
Responding to the ECI's description of files moving from one Election Commissioner to another "and then finally to the Chief Election Commissioner," the petitioner argues: "The Election Commission is not a 'chain of command'. The Election Commissioners are Members of a multi-member constitutional body and are not subordinates of its Chairman." He adds that Section 18 "recognises only two modes of decision-making" and "does not recognise a decision by whichever Member signs last."
Specific Instance: Alteration Of Online Form 6
Applying this to Form 6, the rejoinder states that one Election Commissioner recorded on May 16, 2026, and the other concurred on May 19, that Form 6 could not lawfully be altered without amending the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. The petitioner notes: "Two of three members are a majority. Yet the alteration was implemented in July 2026 and remained until 21.10.2026."
Only two explanations are possible, the petitioner submits: either "the majority opinion was overridden by the member at the end of the file chain, in direct breach of Section 18(2)," or "the alteration was made without any decision of the Commission at all." "On either hypothesis the act was not the act of the Commission."
The petitioner clarifies that his grievance is not that the printed Form 6 was amended. His case is that in July 2026 the online form was altered so that an applicant could not proceed without answering whether he, his parents or grandparents "exist" in the last SIR roll, although the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 prescribe no such field.
Comparison: Statutory Decision-Making Vs Actual Practice
Statutory Requirement (Section 18, 2023 Act) | Alleged Actual Practice |
|---|---|
Decision by unanimous or majority vote of three-member Commission | Decisions implemented by officers/divisions without Commission decision |
Majority opinion of two members binds the Commission | Majority opinion recorded but alteration implemented contrary to it |
Commission is a collective constitutional body | File circulation treated as "chain of command" ending with CEC |
Members are not subordinates of Chairman | Members' notings described as "suggestions" or "queries" |
Election Commissioners Not Subordinates
The ECI's description of members' notings as "suggestions," "observations" or "queries" cannot alter the statutory consequence of a recorded difference of opinion, the rejoinder argues. The petitioner seeks an interim bar on orders not backed by a Section 18 decision, contending that the ECI's post-petition corrections were admissions, not answers, to the fundamental constitutional violation alleged.
The matter remains pending for further hearing before the Supreme Court.
