The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that the mere inclusion of a person's name in a First Information Report or subsequent investigation material, without any specific conduct or material indicating participation in an alleged criminal conspiracy, cannot serve as a basis to subject that person to a criminal trial. A single bench of Justice Rajesh Kumar Gupta quashed an FIR and all consequential proceedings against a law student who had been arrayed as an accused in a case involving kidnapping, abduction to compel marriage, wrongful restraint, and criminal conspiracy.
Factual Background
The petitioner, a law student, approached the High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking quashing of an FIR registered under Sections 140 (kidnapping), 87 (abducting a woman to compel marriage), 126 (wrongful restraint), and 61 (criminal conspiracy) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), along with Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act. The prosecution case, as set out in the FIR lodged by the mother of the prosecutrix, alleged that the prosecutrix was abducted in a white Baleno car while she was at her law college. The FIR specifically named one J.T. as the main accused and referred to another unidentified person driving the vehicle. The petitioner's name did not appear in the FIR.
During the investigation, the petitioner was subsequently arrayed as an accused. The State relied heavily on the statement of the prosecutrix recorded under Section 183 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), in which she referred to the petitioner and another student keeping tabs on her movements. The Public Prosecutor argued that this statement established the petitioner's involvement in supplying information regarding the prosecutrix's movements to the main accused, thereby constituting participation in the conspiracy.
Court's Analysis On FIR And Investigation Material
The bench commenced its analysis by reiterating the settled principle that the power to quash criminal proceedings under inherent jurisdiction must be exercised sparingly and with caution. The core issue, the court noted, was whether the material collected during the investigation disclosed a sufficient factual foundation to attribute any criminal involvement to the petitioner.
The court observed that the FIR itself did not disclose the petitioner's name nor attribute any specific act to him. While acknowledging that the absence of a name in the FIR is not by itself a ground for quashing where subsequent investigation reveals involvement, the bench held that the subsequent material also required careful examination to ascertain a legally sustainable connection.
Examining the prosecutrix's statement under Section 183 BNSS, the court found that no particular act was attributed to the petitioner. The bench noted that when the statement was read in its entirety, it did not disclose any specific instance of communication between the petitioner and the main accused. Crucially, the statement failed to specify the date, time, mode, or nature of any communication allegedly made by the petitioner to facilitate the abduction.
Call Detail Records And Absence Of Overt Acts
The court further scrutinised the Call Detail Records (CDRs) of the petitioner. The records revealed no active communication between the main accused and the petitioner, with the last recorded conversation dating back three months prior to the incident. While the bench acknowledged that the absence of call details would not conclusively rule out the possibility of a conspiracy, it emphasised that in the present case, the allegation against the petitioner rested solely on a vague assertion of "keeping tabs" without any corroborating material.
Justice Gupta observed that the distinction between mere acquaintance with co-accused persons and intentional participation in a criminal conspiracy must be kept in view. The court held that criminal liability cannot be fastened merely because the petitioner was a fellow student or acquaintance of the prosecutrix and the other co-accused. There must be some material, at least prima facie, indicating that the petitioner had knowingly participated in, facilitated, or shared the alleged criminal design.
Mere Mention Of Name Without Evidence Of Role In Criminal Conspiracy Not Enough For Trial?
The Madhya Pradesh High Court held that a bare reference to an accused's name in a statement, devoid of specific allegations regarding the date, time, mode, or nature of participation in the conspiracy, is insufficient to sustain a charge. Without prima facie material showing knowing participation in the criminal design, the court will quash the proceedings.
Disposition
Accordingly, the High Court allowed the petition and quashed the FIR dated 28 September 2024 registered at Police Station Civil Lines, District Rewa, along with all consequential proceedings arising therefrom against the petitioner. The court clarified that the observations made were confined to the limited purpose of deciding the quashing petition and would not influence the trial proceedings against the other accused persons.
