The Delhi High Court on Thursday declined to entertain a writ petition challenging a National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) order that disposed of a complaint by forwarding it to the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police in Sukma, Chhattisgarh. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that the Delhi High Court lacked territorial jurisdiction to adjudicate the matter, directing the petitioner to approach the Chhattisgarh High Court instead.
Background of the Petition
The petitioner, Baman Ram Kawasi, an Adivasi resident of village Chitlanar in Sukma district, filed the plea against the NHRC's decision dated June 9. The Commission had disposed of his complaint by directing the local administration to take appropriate action within eight weeks. Kawasi alleged that Christian Adivasi families in Chitlanar, practising their faith for approximately 18 years, were attacked by a mob on March 5. The mob allegedly demanded conversion to Hinduism or evacuation of the village. Two community members, Santa Barse and Ayte Barse, were reportedly assaulted with sticks and hospitalised, while families received death threats forcing them into makeshift shelters in Sukma town.
Court's Reasoning on Territorial Jurisdiction
The petitioner contended that the Delhi High Court possessed jurisdiction because the NHRC passed the impugned order from its headquarters in New Delhi. The Union of India opposed the plea, submitting that the alleged incidents, victims, local authorities, and all relevant records were situated in Chhattisgarh.
Justice Sharma rejected the petitioner's jurisdictional argument. The court observed that even assuming the passing of the order in New Delhi gave rise to a partial cause of action within its territory, this was insufficient to warrant the exercise of writ jurisdiction. The judge emphasized that the petitioner, the victims, the place of incident, the authorities concerned, and the entire relevant record were all located in District Sukma, Chhattisgarh.
Principle of Forum Conveniens Applied
The court noted that the NHRC had acted merely as a channel by forwarding the complaint to the local authorities against whom the grievance was directed. Adjudicating the petition would require scrutiny of the incidents in Sukma, the alleged inaction of the local police and administration, and the subsequent action taken by them. The court held that accepting the petitioner's argument would lead to an untenable situation where every NHRC order concerning an incident anywhere in the country could be challenged before the Delhi High Court solely because the Commission is headquartered in the national capital.
Why Did the Delhi High Court Dismiss the Plea Against the NHRC Order?
The Delhi High Court dismissed the plea for want of territorial jurisdiction and on the principle of forum conveniens. It ruled that the mere fact that the NHRC passed the order from its Delhi headquarters does not confer jurisdiction on the Delhi High Court, as the cause of action, victims, authorities, and records are entirely situated in Sukma, Chhattisgarh.
Comparison of Jurisdictional Arguments
Aspect | Petitioner's Argument | Court's Finding |
|---|---|---|
Basis of Jurisdiction | NHRC order passed at headquarters in New Delhi | Location of incident, victims, authorities, and records in Sukma, Chhattisgarh |
Cause of Action | Arises in Delhi due to NHRC decision-making | Arises in Chhattisgarh; NHRC acted as a channel forwarding complaint to local authorities |
Implication of Acceptance | Delhi HC can hear challenge | Every NHRC order nationwide challengeable in Delhi, leading to forum shopping |
Appropriate Forum | Delhi High Court | Chhattisgarh High Court |
Operative Outcome
Concluding the judgment, Justice Sharma stated the court was not inclined to entertain the petition for want of territorial jurisdiction and on the principle of forum conveniens. The plea was dismissed, with liberty granted to the petitioner to approach the appropriate forum, including the Chhattisgarh High Court. Advocates Jaiwant Patnakar and Philip John appeared for the petitioner, while the Union of India was represented by Central Government Standing Counsel Premtosh K Mishra, assisted by advocates Krish Bhatia and Vasu Agarwal.
