Calcutta High Court Refuses to Quash Murder Charge Against Promoter In 15-Death Building Collapse Case

HC News

Calcutta High Court Refuses to Quash Murder Charge Against Promoter In 15-Death Building Collapse Case

Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das dismissed a revision petition by promoter Md Wasim, holding that altering the Section 302 IPC charge at the threshold stage would prejudice the prosecution's case given the gravity of allegations regarding unauthorised construction and use of substandard materials.

Hydar Choudhury
3 min read

Follow Jurisight:TelegramWhatsApp

Calcutta High Court Refuses to Quash Murder Charge Against Promoter In 15-Death Building Collapse Case — HC News Legal Analysis | Jurisight
This article was prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the Jurisight Desk.

The Calcutta High Court has declined to interfere with the framing of murder charges against a building promoter in connection with the collapse of a five-storey structure at Azhar Molla Bagan, Kolkata, which claimed fifteen lives on March 18, 2024. Justice Chaitali Chatterjee Das dismissed the revision petition filed by Md Wasim @ Wassi seeking to quash the charges framed by the trial court in December 2024.

The trial court had invoked Sections 302 (murder), 307 (attempt to murder), 427 (mischief causing damage), and 120B (criminal conspiracy) of the Indian Penal Code. The charges followed an inspection by the Kolkata Municipal Corporation which revealed that the construction lacked requisite approvals.

Why did the High Court uphold the murder charge against the promoter?

The Court held that altering the charge to a lesser offence at the threshold stage would severely prejudice the prosecution's ability to address the gravity of the allegations and the petitioner's active role, leaving the trial court to determine culpability upon full appreciation of evidence.

Wasim's counsel contended that the complaint letter did not disclose any act constituting murder and that the essential element of intention or knowledge was absent. It was argued that the petitioner could not have known the specific date and time of the collapse or that fifteen persons, including a co-promoter, would perish.

The prosecution, represented by Public Prosecutor Kallol Mondal with advocates Pritam Roy and Samira Grewal, submitted that the investigation revealed Wasim had directed labourers to mix construction materials in disproportionate quantities and use inferior quality materials for the building's columns. It was further stated that the structure was raised without prior sanction from authorities.

Justice Das observed that the petitioner, despite possessing no requisite technical qualifications, actively involved himself in the construction process. The Court noted that this active involvement, coupled with the alleged use of substandard materials and lack of approvals, resulted in the death of fifteen persons and injuries to several others. The prosecution also brought to the Court's attention the petitioner's alleged criminal antecedents, including a prior offence relating to murder.

The Court concluded that if the charge were altered at this initial stage to a substantially lesser offence, there would hardly remain any scope for the prosecution to proceed effectively with the trial concerning the gravity of the allegations. The trial court was granted the liberty to examine the necessary evidence and decide the ultimate fate of the prosecution case during the trial proceedings.

Provision

Offence

Status

Section 302 IPC

Murder

Charge upheld

Section 307 IPC

Attempt to Murder

Charge upheld

Section 427 IPC

Mischief Causing Damage

Charge upheld

Section 120B IPC

Criminal Conspiracy

Charge upheld

The petitioner was represented by advocates Sandip Kumar Bhattacharya, Dipta Dipak Banerjee, Srijita Dhar, and Srilekha Dhar. The matter pertains to the case Md. Wasim @ Wassi v. State of West Bengal and Anr.

Hydar Choudhury

More stories by Hydar