A Division Bench of the Bombay High Court comprising Justices Sarang V Kotwal and Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale set aside a non-bailable warrant and a subsequent remand order passed by a Judicial Magistrate First Class (JMFC) at Vikhroli, directing the immediate release of an undertrial who had secured bail in all pending cases.
What happens when a magistrate issues a non-bailable warrant against an accused already in judicial custody in another case?
The Bombay High Court held that issuing a non-bailable warrant against an accused who is already in judicial custody in a separate proceeding is legally erroneous. The magistrate must recognise the existing custody and the bail orders already granted, rather than treating the absence as a wilful default.
Background and Factual Matrix
The petitioner, Hitesh Chhotalal Solanki, faced five criminal cases registered across Maharashtra. He had obtained bail in all matters, including an order from a Sessions Court on May 4 granting bail in a case registered at Pant Nagar police station (C.R. No. 1234 of 2025). Despite this, Solanki remained lodged in Thane Central Prison as bail in a separate case registered at Alandi police station was still pending.
When the Pant Nagar case was listed for hearing on July 7, Solanki could not appear before the JMFC because he was in judicial custody in the Alandi matter. The magistrate issued a non-bailable warrant (NBW) against him for non-appearance. On July 15, even after being informed that the accused was already in judicial custody, the JMFC remanded Solanki to magisterial custody in the Pant Nagar case.
Court's Findings on Judicial Oversight
The High Court strongly criticised the magisterial orders. The Bench observed that the JMFC had ignored the subsisting bail order passed by the Sessions Court in the Pant Nagar case. The court noted that the magistrate erred in issuing the NBW despite being aware that the petitioner was in custody in another case and physically incapable of attending the proceedings.
Furthermore, the Bench held that the remand to magisterial custody on July 15 was unjustified. The magistrate failed to appreciate that the accused was already in lawful custody and that the earlier bail order remained operative. The court characterised the continuation of detention as a situation requiring immediate correction.
Comparative Timeline of Orders
Date | Authority | Order | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
May 4 | Sessions Court | Granted bail in Pant Nagar case (C.R. 1234/2025) | Operative but not executed due to Alandi case |
July 7 | JMFC, Vikhroli | Issued Non-Bailable Warrant for non-appearance | Set aside by High Court |
July 15 | JMFC, Vikhroli | Remanded to magisterial custody | Set aside by High Court |
November 19 | Bombay High Court (Division Bench) | Set aside NBW and remand; directed forthwith release | Operative |
Disposition
Allowing the petition, the Division Bench set aside the non-bailable warrant dated July 7 and the remand order dated July 15 passed by the JMFC, Vikhroli. The court directed that the petitioner be released forthwith from custody, noting that he had secured bail in all five cases and his continued detention was unjustified. Advocates Sahil Tejwani, Aditya Navpute, and Gaurav Tejwani appeared for the petitioner, while Additional Public Prosecutor M.M. Deshmukh represented the State.
