Bombay High Court Condemns Public Insensitivity Over Diwali Firecracker Violations, Reserves Order on State-Wide Ban

News

Bombay High Court Condemns Public Insensitivity Over Diwali Firecracker Violations, Reserves Order on State-Wide Ban

A division bench of Justices GS Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale criticised citizens for flouting firecracker restrictions, noting police helplessness and severe post-Diwali pollution, while reserving judgment on a complete ban across Maharashtra.

Jurisight Desk
3 min read

Follow Jurisight:TelegramWhatsApp

Bombay High Court Condemns Public Insensitivity Over Diwali Firecracker Violations, Reserves Order on State-Wide Ban — News Legal Analysis | Jurisight
This article was prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the Jurisight Desk.

The Bombay High Court on Thursday delivered a stern rebuke to the residents of Mumbai for widespread violations of firecracker restrictions during Diwali, observing that the public had displayed a complete lack of civic consciousness. A division bench comprising Justice GS Kulkarni and Justice Neela Gokhale expressed serious concern over the severe deterioration in air and noise pollution levels following the festival, citing reports of Air Quality Index (AQI) levels breaching 400 and over 330 fire incidents caused by stray rockets striking high-rise buildings.

Court Observes Public Insensitivity and Police Helplessness

The bench remarked that people appeared to have no consciousness for the societal cause, questioning why judicial intervention was repeatedly necessary to enforce basic civic discipline. Justice Gokhale observed that the police and municipal machinery were helpless and could not be faulted when citizens willingly indulged in violations. She stated that the authorities had done their best, but the situation was ultimately beyond their control because firecrackers were being burst until 4 am across the city.

What Did the Bombay High Court Say About Social Media's Role in Firecracker Violations?

Justice Gokhale flagged the role of social media in encouraging violations, noting that platforms were replete with instances of people urging others to burst firecrackers for various reasons. The bench treated this as an aggravating factor contributing to the uncontrollable nature of the violations.

Amicus Curiae and Petitioners Highlight Regulatory Failures

Amicus Curiae Anand Pai submitted that there should be a total halt on the sale of firecrackers until authorities designate regulated community firework grounds. Advocate Rohaan Cama, appearing for the petitioners, presented test data indicating that half of the sampled green crackers carried fake QR codes and contained banned barium, underscoring the failure of the existing regulatory framework to ensure compliance.

Retailers Oppose Blanket Ban; Court Cites Supreme Court Precedent

Counsel for the Mumbai and Thane District Fireworks Dealers Welfare Association opposed a blanket prohibition, arguing that licensed traders were being penalised for the actions of illegal vendors. The bench responded by citing Supreme Court orders holding that trade rights under Article 19(1)(g) remain subservient to the right to life under Article 21. The judges clarified that hazardous practices also enjoy no protection under Article 25. Justice Kulkarni stated that while traders may have a right to do business, they do not have a right to harm the lives of people.

Stray Rockets Equated to Residential Intrusion

The court equated the impact of stray rockets entering residential flats to a physical intrusion. The bench remarked that celebrations cannot be permitted to damage another person's property, drawing an analogy to allowing someone to enter a flat and burn firecrackers inside. The judges further highlighted the inequity of the situation, noting that not everybody can afford air purifiers at home to mitigate the pollution.

Order Reserved for State-Wide Application

Before reserving its order, the bench indicated that any forthcoming directions would apply across Maharashtra rather than being limited to urban centres alone. The case, registered as In re: Noise and Environmental Pollution, concerns the imposition of a complete ban on the sale and bursting of firecrackers across the state.