The Allahabad High Court on Friday dropped proceedings against Raj Kulshrestha, who was taken into custody a day earlier for recording a court hearing on his mobile phone without authorisation. Justice Vikram D Chauhan accepted an unconditional apology tendered by Kulshrestha and directed his immediate release. The court also ordered the return of his mobile phone after the deletion of the recorded videos and a reset of the device, while restraining him from publishing any such footage on social media.
The incident originated on November 19 when the court noticed Kulshrestha filming the proceedings. Upon inquiry, he admitted to recording without permission but could not state the purpose. The Bench Secretary seized the phone and discovered three videos of the hearing. The court noted that Kulshrestha had no matter listed before it and had entered the courtroom using a Registry-issued pass permitting access only to the Advocates Chamber. Consequently, the court directed his production before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, and asked him to explain why the unauthorised recording should not be treated as interference with the administration of justice.
Why Did The Court Initiate Proceedings Against The Person Filming The Hearing?
The court initiated proceedings because Kulshrestha recorded proceedings without permission, had no case listed before the court, and entered the courtroom on a pass restricted to the Advocates Chamber, which the court viewed as potential interference with the administration of justice.
When the matter was taken up again on November 20, advocates Nitish Kumar Soni and Bhanu Pratap Seth appeared for the petitioner in the underlying case, Kuldeep Batra. Advocate Soni informed the court he had been out of station on the previous day and had sent Advocate Seth to seek an adjournment. Soni tendered an unconditional apology for the incident. Advocate Seth stated he could not appear alone on November 19 as he was frightened. Kulshrestha, produced in police custody, also tendered an unconditional apology and undertook to maintain court decorum and refrain from recording proceedings in future.
The court further recorded that the petitioner, Batra, had entered the courtroom using a pass meant for the Advocates Chamber. Advocate Soni attributed the incorrect pass to an office error and apologised unconditionally. Taking these submissions on record, Justice Chauhan observed that the proceedings could be dropped in view of the admitted mistakes and apologies.
Despite closing the proceedings, the single judge clarified that the direction issued on November 19 prohibiting litigants from carrying mobile phones into the courtroom would remain in force. The bench stated that mobile phones may be kept in the office of the concerned advocate or deposited elsewhere. The court also directed that its November 19 order be placed before the Division Bench hearing the suo motu public interest litigation concerning security and protection in all court campuses in Uttar Pradesh, for consideration of measures to enforce the restriction on mobile phones inside courtrooms.
In its November 19 order, the court had elaborated on the principle of open justice. It held that while court proceedings are generally open to the public, this principle does not confer a right of free broadcast by an unauthorised individual. The court highlighted that matters involving individual liberty, child sexual abuse, the Central Bureau of Investigation, the Enforcement Directorate, and cases concerning Members of Parliament and Legislative Assemblies often contain facts not required to be published on social media without judicial determination. The court further remarked that court proceedings are not for entertainment purposes.
Aspect | November 19 Order | November 20 Order |
|---|---|---|
Action Taken | Directed custody of Kulshrestha; production before CJM; initiated inquiry into interference with administration of justice. | Dropped proceedings; directed release of Kulshrestha; returned phone after data deletion. |
Key Reasoning | Unauthorised recording; no listed case; entry via Advocates Chamber pass; principle of open justice not a right of free broadcast. | Unconditional apologies by Kulshrestha, Advocates Soni and Seth; undertaking for future conduct; office error regarding petitioners pass. |
Mobile Phone Ban | Prohibited litigants from carrying mobile phones into courtrooms. | Clarified ban continues; phones to be kept in advocates office or elsewhere; order referred to Division Bench in suo motu PIL. |
Open Justice Observation | Elaborated that open access does not equal right to broadcast; cited sensitive case categories (POCSO, CBI, ED, MPs/MLAs). | Reiterated continuation of restrictions; no fresh observations on open justice principle. |
The operative outcome reflects a balance between enforcing courtroom decorum and accepting genuine contrition. While the contemnor was released, the court reinforced structural safeguards by continuing the mobile phone prohibition and seeking its institutionalisation through the pending suo motu proceedings on court security.
