Also Read - HP High Court Orders Transfer of Kullu Officials and SIT Probe into Kasol Rave Parties

Furthermore, the plea asserts that the freedom to express grief, sympathy and spiritual solidarity through peaceful assembly falls within the ambit of Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(b). The executive may not curtail these rights unless there is an imminent and verified threat to public order, a condition which, according to the petitioner, was absent in the cited incidents.

The petition also invokes the religious freedom safeguarded by Articles 25 and 26. It draws a parallel between the status of a Marja‑e‑Taqlid in Twelver Shia theology and that of the Pope in Christianity, contending that equating the peaceful commemoration of the deceased leader with a security threat constitutes a direct intrusion upon the religious conscience of the community.

Also Read - Madhya Pradesh High Court Grants Bail to Supplier and Medical Representative in Coldriff Cough Syrup Case

To substantiate the claim that the community’s practice of Azadari, including the carrying of banners and portraits, is longstanding, the pleading notes that such observances have been carried out by Shia Muslims in Uttar Pradesh for generations. It further points out that the Union of India, through the Ministry of External Affairs, formally acknowledged the international stature of the late leader by extending official condolences and participating in diplomatic mourning protocols, thereby underscoring that the sentiment expressed by the community is not antithetical to national interests.

The petitioner states that a detailed representation was submitted to the state’s highest home and police authorities on June 12, 2026. Receiving no response or remedial action, the body approached the High Court to prevent a reasonably apprehended chilling effect on the community’s forthcoming Muharram‑ul‑Haram observances.

Also Read - Madhya Pradesh High Court Allows Woman's Plea for Abortion Despite Estranged Husband Remaining Unrepresented

The relief sought in the public interest litigation includes a direction to the District Police Heads, Superintendents of Police and Station House Officers across Uttar Pradesh to desist from taking any coercive action or effecting detentions against individuals who are peacefully participating in religious mourning or displaying portraits of spiritual leaders. The plea also seeks an order restraining the police from registering first information reports solely on the basis of such peaceful expressions of grief.

As of the date of filing, the matter is pending before the Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court, which has yet to pronounce any order or observation on the substantive prayers of the petition.

Also Read - Appointment to New Post After Abolition of Old One Not a Promotion for MACP Benefits: Meghalaya High Court